Tag Archives: envoc

Oh, Florida (mobile driver’s licenses)

I should properly open this post by stating any necessary disclosures…but I don’t have any. I know NOTHING about the goings-on reported in this post other than what I read in the papers.

“I know NOTHING.” By CBS Television – eBayfrontback, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=73578107.

However, I do know the history of Thales and mobile driver’s licenses. Which makes the recent announcements from Florida and Thales even more surprising.

Gemalto’s pioneering mobile driver’s license pilots

Back when I worked for IDEMIA from 2017 to 2020, many states were performing some level of testing of mobile driver’s licenses. Rather than having to carry a physical driver’s license card, you would be able to carry a virtual one on your phone.

While Louisiana was the first state to release an operational mobile driver’s license (with Envoc’s “LA Wallet”), several states were working on pilot projects.

Some of these states were working with the company Gemalto to create pilots for mobile driver’s licenses. As early as 2016, Gemalto announced its participation in pilot mDL projects in Colorado, Idaho, Maryland, and Washington DC. As I recall, at the time Gemalto had more publicly-known pilots in process than any other vendor, and appeared to be leading the pack in the effort to transition driver’s licenses from the (physical) wallet to the smartphone.

Thales’ operational mobile driver’s license

By the time Gemalto was acquired by and absorbed into Thales, the company won the opportunity to provide an operational (as opposed to pilot) driver’s license. The Florida Smart ID app has been available to both iPhone and Android users since 2021.

From https://www.flhsmv.gov/floridasmartid/ as of July 12. No idea whether this image will still be there on July 15.

What just happened?

This morning I woke up to a slew of articles (such as the LinkedIn post from PEAK IDV’s Steve Craig, and the Biometric Update post from Chris Burt) that indicated the situation had changed.

One of the most important pieces of new information was a revised set of Frequently Asked Questions (or “Question,” or “Statement”) on the “Florida Smart ID” section of the Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles website.

The Florida Smart ID applications will be updated and improved by a new vendor. At this time, the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles is removing the current Florida Smart ID application from the app store. Please email FloridaSmartID@flhsmv.gov to receive notification of future availability.

Um…that was abrupt.

But a second piece of information, a Thales statement shared by PC Mag, explained the abruptness…in part.

In a statement provided to PCMag, a Thales spokesperson said the company’s contract with the FLHSMV expired on June 30, 2024.

“The project has now entered a new phase in which the FLHSMV requirements have evolved, necessitating a retender,” Thales says. “Thales chose not to compete in this tender. However, we are pleased to have been a part of this pioneering solution and wishes it continued success.”

Now normally when a government project transitions from one vendor to another, the old vendor continues to provide the service until the date that the new vendor’s system is operational. This is true even in contentious cases, such as the North Carolina physical driver’s license transition from IDEMIA to CBN Secure Technologies.

But in the Florida case:

  • Thales chose not to bid on the contract renewal.
  • The new vendor and/or the State of Florida chose not to begin providing services when the Thales contract expired on June 30.
  • Thales and/or the State of Florida chose not to temporarily renew the existing contract until the new vendor was providing services in 2025.

This third point is especially odd. I’ve known of situations where Company A lost a renewal bid to Company B, Company B was unable to deliver the new system on time, and Company A was all too happy to continue to provide service until Company B (or in some cases the government agency itself) got its act together.

Anyway, for whatever reason, those who had Florida mobile driver’s licenses have now lost them, and will presumably have to go through an entirely new process (with an as-yet unknown vendor) to get their mobile driver’s licenses again.

I’m not sure how much more we will learn publicly, and I don’t know how much is being whispered privately. Presumably the new vendor, whoever it is, has some insight, but they’re not talking.

Android mobile driver’s licenses? It’s complicated.

At least in the United States, the mobile driver’s license world is fragmented.

Because driver’s license issuance in the U.S. is a state and not a federal responsibility, each state has to develop its own mobile driver’s license implementation. Subject to federal and international standards, of course.

To date there have been two parties helping the states with this:

  • mDL vendors such as Envoc and IDEMIA, who work with the states to create mDLs.
  • Operating system vendors such as Apple and Google, who work with the states to incorporate mDLs in smartphone wallets.

But because the Android ecosystem is more fragmented than the iOS ecosystem, we now have a third party that is involved in mDLs. In addition to mDL vendors and operating system vendors, we also have really large smartphone providers.

From https://news.samsung.com/us/samsung-idemia-bring-mobile-drivers-licenses-samsung-wallet-arizona-iowa-first-states-rollout/

Enter Samsung:

Samsung Electronics America today announced it is bringing mobile driver’s licenses and state IDs to Samsung Wallet. Arizona and Iowa will be the first states to offer a mobile version of its driver’s license to their residents. The update expands the Samsung Wallet experience by adding a convenient and secure way to use state-issued IDs and driver’s licenses

From https://news.samsung.com/us/samsung-idemia-bring-mobile-drivers-licenses-samsung-wallet-arizona-iowa-first-states-rollout/

(For those who have seen prior references to Samsung in the Bredemarket blog, rest assured that this information is public and Samsung won’t get harmed if you feed it to ChatGPT or Bard or whoever.)

In this particular case Samsung is working with IDEMIA (the mDL provider for Arizona and Iowa), but Samsung announced that it is working with other states and with the Transportation Security Administration (TSA).

While there are underlying standards (most notably ISO/IEC 18013-5, previously discussed here) that govern the implementation of mobile driver’s licenses, there is still a dizzying array of options.

From https://www.yourtango.com/201168184/facebook-relationship-status-what-does-its-complicated-mean

On a personal note, I’m still working on validating my driver’s license for California’s pilot mDL program. It probably didn’t help that I renewed my physical driver’s license right in the middle of the mDL validation process.