Warring Government Digital Identity Standards: Vendor Wars, Or Agency Wars?

To no one’s surprise, the federal government is experiencing warring government digital identity standards. And for once I can’t answer the “why” question.

You may remember my September post “Universal” Login.gov Access Within Two Years. It quoted from a memorandum:

“SUBJECT: Scaling Use of Login.gov to Deliver a Universal Sign-on for Public Services”

Now I noted that “universal” does not necessarily mean “exclusive.” My read of the memorandum indicates that agencies can continue to offer CLEAR and ID.me…as long as they also offer Login.gov. And the agencies have to say what their preferred solution can do that Login.gov can’t do.

But that was September. Let’s fast forward to October.

TreasuryDirect goes its own way

“You can go your own way”

(Lindsey Buckingham)

Demonstrating that the federal government offers the stability shown by the marriages of 1970s Fleetwood Mac (and ABBA), officials at the Department of the Treasury aren’t fans of the memorandum. Biometric Update:

“Since October 28, ID.me has been the only way to log into TreasuryDirect. Customers who decline to create an ID.me account can still manage investments using paper processes, but risk losing online access to their accounts and tax documents.”

This concerned two very powerful members of the U.S. Senate. But before I get to their strongly worded letter, I have a story. A tale about one of these two Senators, Ron Wyden.

Draw Ronnie

In the spring of 1980 I was a college student in Oregon, and a maverick upstart politician targeted my college’s students to get votes. Now many of us were from out of state and registered in our home states. But we were reminded that we could change our voter registration to Oregon.

At the time. the Portland area’s representative in the U.S. House was Robert Duncan. He had served in the House since 1975. However, he had previously represented the Medford area from 1963 to 1967. Rather than run for the House again in 1966, he ran for the Senate…and lost to popular Governor (and Vietnam War opponent) Mark Hatfield.

In 1980, Duncan was challenged by a young 31 year old upstart, Ron Wyden. A law school graduate who had never passed the Oregon bar exam, he was known for founding the Oregon chapter of the Gray Panthers. He was also the director of the Oregon Legal Services Center for Elderly. But he also appealed to college students, taking out an ad in our newspaper and promising to “make a difference.” The ad featured a headshot of Wyden with a big smile.

Ron Wyden circa 1980.

Next thing we knew, those newspaper headshots (printed, not digital; it was 1980) were the centerpiece of a “Draw Ronnie” campaign. Actual a coloring campaign rather than a drawing campaign, we were encouraged to alter Wyden’s smiling faces with clown noses and the like.

Despite this irreverence (or perhaps because of it), Wyden upset Duncan in the 1980 Democratic primary. He then won the general election. Wyden served in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1981 to 1997. He then moved to the U.S. Senate. As of November 2026 Wyden is the Ranking Member (minority party leader) of the Senate Finance Committee. Elizabeth Warren is also on that committee.

A strongly worded letter

So when the Department of the Treasury shut Login.gov out, Senators Wyden and Warren sent a strongly worded letter to Treasury and the IRS. They basically asked what ID.me can do that Login.gov can’t do—and why Login.gov was shut out.

A few years ago there was an issue because Login.gov didn’t meet Identity Assurance Level 2 (IAL2), but Login.gov now meets this requirement.

And the Senators acknowledge that “Login.gov may not serve some taxpayers living abroad or using Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers, and say alternative providers may remain necessary for those users.” But Login.gov should work fine for everyone else.

So why is Treasury…um…bucking the trend?

  • Is it just slow in acknowledging that Login.gov now meets IAL2?
  • Or perhaps the agencies are fighting with each other?

Yet again, so much for standards.

Leave a Comment